James Strawbridge’s Triple Cheese and Mushroom Sourdough Toastie 

James Strawbridge's Triple Cheese & Mushroom Toastie Portrait

There’s a cheese toastie and then there’s this cheese toastie! Three types of tasty cheese and sautéed mushrooms, delicately flavoured with rosemary and a hefty dollop of red onion chutney for the ultimate indulgent sandwich.

Serves 2



  1. To cook the mushrooms, sauté them on a high heat for 8-10 mins with 2/3 of the butter and the rosemary, until the mushrooms are golden brown. Season to taste with sea salt and cracked black pepper. 
  2. To assemble each toastie (this recipe caters for two toasties), spread the chutney onto one slice of sourdough and then place the cooked mushrooms on top. Cover with a generous amount of each of the three cheeses and sandwich together with another slice of sourdough. Repeat for the second toastie. 
  3. Next, melt the remaining butter and brush over both sides of each toastie. Place into a sandwich press or a heavy cast iron skillet and cook for 4-5 mins until the cheese melts and the buttered bread transforms into a golden crust. Serve with extra red onion chutney. 
James Strawbridge's Triple Cheese & Mushroom Toastie Header

Get this recipe’s ingredients in one easy bundle.

  • Add to basket

    Recipe Bundle: Triple Cheese and Mushroom Sourdough Toastie


The Green Grass and High Tides Podcast

In this podcast collaboration with 44 Foods, James explores some of his favourite ingredients from the land and coast of Britain.

More recipes from James

James Strawbridge’s Triple Cheese and Mushroom Sourdough Toastie 

View Recipe

James Strawbridge’s Spiced Plum and Apple Crumble

View Recipe

James Strawbridge’s Fiery Corn on the Cob with Chilli Jam Butter

View Recipe

James Strawbridge's Mackerel Puttanesca

View Recipe

James Strawbridge’s Egg and Hot Smoked Salmon Breakfast Croissant

View Recipe

James Strawbridge’s Padrón Peppers with Herb Oil

View Recipe

Back to Top